It could be said, as some victim's parents do, that if children act like adults, they should be tried as adults. One way to do this would be for communities to step in. For example, if person x has an age of 31, his brain would be more developed and he would recognize the consequences of his action, when compared to person y , who has an age of 14. They would first serve their prison term in a juvenile facility, and then transferred to an adult prison at the age of 18, which leaves plenty of room for the girls to become targets of abuse. A significantly higher proportion of the criminal group were subsequently reincarcerated 56% vs. Do you make a broad statement about all violent crimes as California has? There are viable points to be made on both sides of the argument and this is not a debate that looks ready to die down anytime soon. Williams is one of many young adults facing the prospect of life in prison as the debate over whether should be tried as adults rages on.
I feel he does deserve to be tried as an adult. They deserve punishment, but not the same punishments as adults, who we look up upon as being responsible people, are given. Deter and minimize crimes committed by minors There is no denying that crimes committed by minors are on the rise. In addition, according to the U. These policies would lead us into a better world and a more law-abiding youth, at no cost, as opposed to raising the law to an absolute status and violating the rights of the child that were declared and agreed on years ago. Shawn was 16 in 1998 when… 1884 Words 8 Pages every day in the United States. By the facts and opinions that I have stated, I believe that juveniles should not be tried as adults.
Spending a few nights in jail around hardened criminals can often be the wake up call that a juvenile offender needs in order to realize the error of their ways and make the necessary changes to their lifestyle. Juvenile crimes on the rise are not something society should ignore. List of Pros of Juveniles Being Tried as Adults 1. For a juvenile case to be transferred to an adult criminal court, it has to be eligible for a waiver. When it comes down to it, people need to know the difference between wrong and right, and every action you take has a consequence.
Statistics compiled from 15 states revealed that juveniles prosecuted in adult court and released from state prisons were rearrested 82 percent of the time, while their adult counterparts were rearrested 16 percent less. A 1996 Florida study authored by Northeastern University researcher Donna Bishop also found that juveniles transferred to the criminal system were not less likely to reoffend, but in fact often had higher rates of recidivism. And as a result of decisions in 2010 and 2012, states are now prohibited from imposing life sentences on juveniles. Casey Foundation But although the youth incarceration rate in the U. Lennie Irvin English 1301-279 April 29, 2012 Should Juveniles be tried as Adults? Sixteen year olds do not know that much more than thirteen year olds and they should both be charged as adolescents.
The Pros of Juveniles Being Tried As Adults 1. There should be a different place for youth offenders. These rates were compared with those for control groups of thirteen and fourteen year olds in Philadelphia, and with slightly older offenders in New York. Also punishing teens will reduce crime rates in the future because these teens will potentially commit more crimes as an adult. Once a troubled juvenile is sent to an adult prison, they are out of the way of society. Should Juveniles Be Tried as Adults. In my opinion, this was a moral and just decision.
If a juvenile is beyond that age, they are automatically within the jurisdiction of adult criminal court, regardless of the offense charged. Growing up we should already know right and wrong at that age. Many think that cracking down on serious juvenile crime and trying to scare kids straight by threatening them with adult sentences will decrease crime but this can lead to more crime later. Pro Certain juvenile offenders should be tried as adults. Learn More About Juveniles and the Justice System The United States locks up more kids than any other industrialized nation in the world. Yet for those who commit great crimes should be tried to a maximum of 25-30 years.
There is even a high probability that they would come out of prison a hardened criminal. Both states had similar statutes for first- and second-degree robbery and first-degree burglary. Brings justice to the victims Some offenses may be forgivable, but not for extreme crimes similar to what the Wisconsin girls committed. And they are more likely to be victimized sexually. The problem is that we are looking at the wrong side of this. To date, only two studies have examined whether stricter transfer laws result in lowered juvenile crime rates.
Finally, I believe that by being rehabilitated the juvenile will have a better chance at life because eventually they will be back in society. The Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention report evaluated a study of outcomes for juveniles prosecuted in adult court rather than in juvenile court and found that there were counter-deterrent effects of transfer laws. Their freedom deserves to be taken away from them, but they still deserve minimal freedom. Juvenile offenders should not be tried as adults because when given the death penalty they endure societal alienation. They do this without any thought towards the child? Other factors attributed to this include; child abuse, parental neglect, poverty, exposure to media violence, accessibility to illegal arms. I would like to thank the opponent for instigating this debate. They examined arrest rates for five years before and five years after the passage of the law, and found no evidence that it had any deterrent effect on the level of juvenile crime in Idaho.