If the selling of organs was legalized, there would be an increased rate of murders. Should someone be able to sell his organ to a person in need? There are only about 20,000 kidneys every year for the approximately 80,000 patients on the waiting list. In short, if you apply a commodity value to a human organ, then you introduce a system where a one person's organs can be forcibly harvested to satisfy a debt. You don't know much about how close we are to cloning organs in test tube; we ain't. Selling organs; two alternate plans.
Several years ago, transplant surgeon Nadley Hakim at St. Everybody should have to same right to life, independently of their financial situation. According to him, people should do what they decide with their body. People cannot have a good life unless they are healthy. Eight thousand people are on the transplant waiting list, more than 500 of whom die each year before they obtain an organ, and the numbers are rising by 8 per cent a year. Although a large number of articles were written, numerous speeches were made, countless meetings were hold to discuss about this matter but until now it is still a big controversy issue all over the world.
My topic is whether we should legalize or illegalize sales of human organs. First of all, organ transplant plays an important role in the medicine. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. You are also allowed to donate blood here, and you will usually get things in return such as free movie tickets or t-shirts. Money should not be all that matters but the lives of the others around us. As with many government policies, the catastrophic results have been contrary to the original intent of patient safety. Lives are at stake here and everyone who needs an organ should have a chance to get one.
This is a counterargument that holds quite a lot of weight, but the manner in which this counterargument is raised holds the legibility issue nonetheless. The need for blood transfusion in medical facilities allows people to sell their blood. Even without the legalization of the sale of organs, many people still receive the organs they need. If the government sets the price of organs at a reasonable level, it is likely that donors will engage in legal trade within the country instead of selling their organs illegally to middlemen. Well, honestly, I've heard a lot of people saying that selling organs can only be good, but I believe that it will only promote more trafficking and the like. Please to join the community! Now those same people are healthy and well. Is it legal, ethical or even economically sound to create a market for the sale of a kidney? Why not apply the same principle to organs? Furthermore, this solution can limit transplant tourism, as overseas organ trade is prohibited.
Well, consider that many people don't sign donor cards now because of distrust or mistrust. Iran is a country that exemplifies a successful outcome of legalization of organ selling. You hold her lifeless body in your arms, wondering how it could be that in all this time, no donor could be found. You can make the moral distinction that these resources are not produced in their finished state by human endeavor and therefore cannot be claimed as private property. On the other hand, organ donation poses more health concerns involving major operations and involve a more detailed match inside a much smaller supply.
And I do think that Organ donation is a very good idea, but I think that this will make the supply go up to match the demand. Your claims show a basic lack of understanding of economics. A legal framework for Bioethics. Living people can donate part of the lung, liver, intestines, or pancreas. Human organs should be given freely because life is given freely to us. Imagine a futures market in organs where individuals contract to provide their organs after their deaths, and in return receive a payment now, or designate the payment to be provided after their deaths to their families or to a charity. Since these organs are your property, I believe you should be able to sell them.
Demand for medical care does not stop when someone is added to the waiting list. In doing so, you would make this technology only available to the ultra wealthy who could buy the equipment and hire the people need to grow an organ since the service of growing one could not be provided as part of a business plan. It can also help to save lives. Only healthy, screened persons would be able to donate their organs and not just people who are alcoholics or on drugs and looking for an easy way to make money. It will not only increase the amount of organs donated that will escalate the possibility of saving lives, but it will also eliminate the black market or underground economy by having faster transaction because of nearer sources.
But that day is long in the future. We can still keep it illegal to drug someone and steal their kidneys, while legalizing organ sales through more reputable, safer means. In the next year, nearly 4,000 of those patients will die waiting. Desperate organ receivers would be forced into paying outrageous prices if organs were on the market. Why the sale of human organs should be legalized.