History, nonetheless, shows these feelings to be tragically unreliable as a safeguard against cruelty to children. In some cases, the parents -- already stressed from long days at work and having no desire to spend precious hours at home squabbling with children -- simply surrendered. While increasing economic growth has several advantages to the nation and inhabitants of the nation, it has its fair share of disadvantages. Dictionary of Biblical Imagery, page 734 So here we have a well-known Bible scholar, Leland Ryken, saying that Proverbs speaks of a literal interpretation of the usage of rods on children. Actually, the mothers who reported being angry were not the same parents who spanked. Con My first point would be the way you made it sound like the only way to strengthen a child is by spanking.
Do you respect anyone who would hit you now? In the days when spanking was a popular form of discipline not only in homes but in schools I do not believe discipline should leave the hands of the parents this is just a reference children were much more well-behaved. Counterpoint: Parental power is commonly exerted in routine child rearing and spanking is only one example. In the case of spanking there are a few things. Argument 1: Many psychological studies show that spanking is an improper form of discipline. Many parents decide to use spanking as a method of discipline. She was mad at me and decided to open the door. Countless lives are carelessly lost every day.
I have just recently come to light on all of my own personal burdens that have come from growing up like this. You don't need to hit your child to teach them what they did was wrong. The most effective of these, is spanking. Another study published in the Akron Law Review last year examined criminal records and found that children raised where a legal ban on parental corporal punishment is in effect are much more likely to be involved in crime. She comments that punishments in schools today need improvement. Caning, Corporal punishment, Corporal punishment in the home 1501 Words 4 Pages Spanking a child, Abuse? At the very least, corporal punishment should help maintain order in the classroom. Toddlers do not remember things very long, so any praise or consequences need to happen immediately and every time the behavior occurs.
The question of whether a swat on the behind is an acceptable method of discipline has bedeviled parents, divided pediatricians who were split close to 50-50 in one survey and spawned impassioned anti-spanking and pro-spanking camps. Corporal punishment, Family, Parent 1153 Words 3 Pages Spanking Spanking — to slap with one's open hand or a flat object, especially on the buttocks as a punishment. Ryken provides a good picture of two different types of rods typically used in the biblical times. It may not be too cynical to wonder if some pro-spanking leaders are reluctant to pin down all the harsh disciplinarians out there--who after all comprise a substantial base of ardent support for their agenda. Many cultures do not like to spank their children others also want to spank their children. Unlike many non-physical punishments, moreover, a spanking is naturally irrevocable, difficult to make up for should a child be subsequently vindicated, and, most importantly, prone to dangerous escalation. Christians differ in their reaction to these biblical passages: Most religious liberals probably feel that these passages merely reflect the child-raising customs of the age.
First, they limited their meta-analysis to studies that evaluated the effects of spanking, slapping and hitting children without the use of objects, and found that spanking is still associated with negative outcomes. Leonard Eron found no association between punishment including spanking and later aggression. If only the psychological effect of pleasure and pain on humans were limited to the immediate reinforcement of certain targeted behaviors, the authors' aseptic reasoning might seem very practical. First off, what is Child Punishment? There are other ways to punish your child than laying a hand or object on them. But the findings did not change his view that spanking is harmful. Milder forms of discipline, such as verbal correction, time-out, and logical consequences, should be used initially, followed by spanking when noncompliance persists.
Some people are very opinionated on the subject and feel it is their duty to instill upon others the correct way to go about the 18 or longer year process. Introduction: You hear more and more every day about a mother or a father accidentally killing their child for a small misbehavior. It is to be expected that increasing attention is being paid to corporal punishment of children. Rather than dividing this range into a few imprecise sections, it makes practical sense to express it all in a single variable. But in that study, parents were just asked how many times they spanked their kid in the past month.
Arguments over how it should be carried out and how harsh it should be has been discussed. Tend to get too emotional. It should also be noted that Dr. Whaley Submitted: October 31, 2013 Running Head: spanking children and cognitive and behavioral problems Introduction Cognitive problems can be defined as having difficulties with thinking, learning and memory. Try to read between the lines too often, making an issue bigger than it needs to be. I needed the lesson to be immediate and effective.
As much as inconsequentiality might make spanking harder to object to, it also makes spanking less justifiable in the first place. In fact, the adults should be expected to behave like adults, and retain their composite and logic instead of lashing out at the kid for having emotions and setting a terrible example for the kid to follow as well. This rationale for spanking is somewhat resigned to the human fallibility of parents, who like everyone else lose their temper at times and who may be caught off guard by the continual trials of raising children. A new meta-analysis addresses several of the most contentious points in the debate and concludes that spanking does pose risks, but differences of opinion persist. Parenting children is a very difficult task, one of the most challenging things anyone will ever encounter.
The etiology of abusive parenting is multifactorial with emphasis on the personalities involved, and cannot be simply explained by a parent's use of spanking. The fact that many successful day care services have policies of no physical punishment shows just how non-essential spanking really is to the management of children's behavior. In Oregon spanking is not only outlawed in the schools, but has been outlawed in the home as well! In a world where children are raised in a non-traditional fashion, physical discipline is a mere distant memory. The pro birth control side believes we must know in the war of birth control what exactly we are fighting for, teens are going to have to sex before marriage regardless, and parents have to do what they can to minimize the effects of it. Some people see spanking as an outdated method of punishment or even child abuse, while others view a swat on the bottom as a parent's prerogative. A spanking is hardly abuse. A man named Ivan Pavlov founded this theory.